Chicago Sun-Times Jim Emerson |
7 |
...[it] may not present the most effective or airtight case against the MPAA, what it does dig up is damning enough. |
Chicago Tribune Michael Phillips |
6 |
It's fun for a while. Then you realize all this Michael Moore-ish folderol is weakening the movie's strongest arguments. |
E! Dezhda Mountz |
10 |
...a quirky, engaging, and unashamed expose. |
filmcritic.com Chris Barsanti |
5 |
|
New York Post Lou Lumenick |
7 |
While This Film Is Not Yet Rated does not suggest an alternative to the ratings board, it does expose this Tinseltown sham to some well-deserved public ridicule. |
TV Guide Maitland McDonagh |
7 |
...hugely entertaining. |
Reel James Emanuel Shapiro |
7 |
Dick's film is funny and clever, and it presents its arguments well, but there's a certain futility to it. |
Slant Magazine Nick Schager |
7 |
...a Molotov cocktail leveled against the Jack Valenti-led Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) and their protocol of secretive, hypocritical, arbitrary, and moralizing censorship of "mature" material. |
Rolling Stone Peter Travers |
8 |
Kirby Dick's indispensable guerrilla attack on the film-ratings system gives Hollywood a swift, smart and hilarious kick in its institutional, hypocritical ass. |
Entertainment Weekly Owen Gleiberman |
8 |
...has a bright, dishy spirit, an eagerness to provoke of the very sort that the MPAA has always tried to put in its place. |
New York Times A. O. Scott |
9 |
...a feisty, intellectually engaging documentary... |
Los Angeles Times Carina Chocano |
7 |
...the film makes a strong -- if occasionally bratty -- case for change. |
People
Jason Lynch |
7 |
...riveting... |
LA Weekly Ella Taylor |
8 |
...merry and bright and loads of fun. |
Village Voice J. Hoberman |
7 |
...a snappy exposé... |
Onion AV Club Scott Tobias |
8 |
...thoroughly eviscerates the MPAA and makes a solid case that the culture has paid the price for its censorious practices. His attacks are the equivalent of shooting ducks in a barrel, but these ducks had it coming. |
Premiere Jared Shimizu |
6 |
...the high drama of unmasking the ratings board members doesn't quite pay off... |
Christian Science Monitor M.K. Terrell |
7 |
Anyone who thinks movie ratings are arbitrary won't be surprised at this attempt to document their inconsistencies. |