watch list   [0 movies]
 

Fateless (2005)

aka:  Sorstalanság

Fateless

Foreign / Drama

2 hrs. 16 min.

Artistic meditation on the Holocaust from Hungarian cinematographer Lajos Koltai, based on a novel about a 14-year-old Jewish boy who survives a concentration camp but must then learn to survive the liberation, which also proves difficult.

Not Rated

Directed by:  Lajos Koltai

Starring:  Endre Harkanyi, Marcell Nagy, Aron Dimeny, Andras M. Kecskes, Joszef Gyabronka

Theatrical Release Date:  1/06/2006

Release Type:  NY

U.S. Box Office: $195,888

Video/DVD Release Date:  5/09/2006

Distributor:  ThinkFilm

Country:  Hungary / Germany / UK

Language:  Hungarian / English / German

Offsite:  IMDB | Official Site



CRITIC
RATING
QUOTE
Chicago Tribune
Michael Wilmington
8 ...a work that sears the heart and conscience. The events are annihilating, the way they're told both beautiful and terrifying.
E!
6 ...suffers from inevitable comparisons to other, better Holocaust dramas.
filmcritic.com
Chris Barsanti
8 ...not a necessarily hopeful film, but it’s also definitely not a cynical one; it may even be a great one.
New York Post
Kyle Smith
9 Profound and majestic.
TV Guide
Ken Fox
9 ...uncompromisingly explicit and emotionally wrenching...
Reel
Tim Knight
8 A wrenching yet hauntingly beautiful film...
Slant Magazine
Ed Gonzalez
6 None of it is uninteresting, except Fateless suggests a new kind of emotionless Holocaust drama...
Rolling Stone
Peter Travers
8 ...a unique and devastating look at the Holocaust...
Entertainment Weekly
Lisa Schwarzbaum
9 ...disturbingly beautiful...
New York Times
A. O. Scott
9 ...ranks among the best nondocumentary cinematic treatments of the Holocaust yet produced.
Los Angeles Times
Kevin Crust
9 A first-rate contribution to the Holocaust canon...
LA Weekly
Ella Taylor
9 ...remarkably tough-minded...
Village Voice
J. Hoberman
9 ...quietly audacious...
Onion AV Club
Noel Murray
9 ...strangely beautiful...
Christian Science Monitor
Peter Rainer
10 This is a Holocaust movie that is so relentlessly observed and so aware of woe that it never feels like it belongs to a genre.
     

WATCH THE TRAILER

This movie is available on DVD/Video

ALL AVERAGE CRITIC RATING 8.4
AVERAGE USER RATING
(2 ratings)
7.5
USER REVIEWS:

Oracle  9

A Strange tale that senses the mind, and the soul......

Grade: A-

The visual beauty of Lajos Koltai's "Fateless" is unmistakable, and also a bit disconcerting. After all, a movie about the holocaust is never happy. But the beauty inside "Fateless" comes from not the suffering, but the outstanding filmmaking.

"Fateless" is a strange tale that senses the mind, and the soul.

"Fateless", nominated for Best Foreign Film, provides a piece of the holocaust from the eyes of Gyuri(Marcell Nagy). Through the great eyes, and great pride this boy has, we see him fall, at more than 1 concentration camp. But he never stops acting with such a great talent, even when he falls.

In the camp, he finds kindness, in particular from a fellow Hungarian (Aron Dimeny). He also discovers that the ordinary course of life yields moments of pleasure. In his voice-over, he speaks of loving the hour of idleness between work and the nighttime roll call. He and the other inmates eat their vile rations not only with desperation, but with relish as well, when they discover a scrap of meat or a potato. The ability to wring such satisfactions from nearly absolute deprivation is one of the ways the prisoners hold on to their humanity.

When he returns to Budapest, he finds himself looking at nothing but ruins. Luckily, he finds old Family freinds, and from there the story is Straight-Forward.

But what makes these scenes in Budapest so eerily beautiful is the great camera movement and the narrative.

In One beautiful last shot, you find Gyuri walking to his mothers house, and as the camera zooms away, and Gyuri explaining the relativity of his experience, you find both fate, and hope clashed together.

-Oracle